Skip to Main Content
Frequently Asked Questions
Submit an ETD
Global Search Box
Need Help?
Keyword Search
Participating Institutions
Advanced Search
School Logo
Files
File List
osu1196050100.pdf (1.33 MB)
ETD Abstract Container
Abstract Header
Virtue nationalism: an aristotelian defense of the nation
Author Info
Aguilar, Abigail Pfister
Permalink:
http://rave.ohiolink.edu/etdc/view?acc_num=osu1196050100
Abstract Details
Year and Degree
2007, Doctor of Philosophy, Ohio State University, Philosophy.
Abstract
Nationalism, it is argued, is a bad ideology, responsible for much of the problems of the modern world. The proofs offered to support this are empirical, in the many reprehensible acts of actual nations. Yet this criticism neglects the possibility that nations may produce, overall, more benefit than harm. A stronger argument against nationalism is theoretical, which claims that all nations are necessarily either amoral or immoral. This argument relies on the set of inherent components that all nations have, and makes the case that these must combine to create a problematic ideology because they always lead to a political structure that allows unacceptable inequalities and unjustifiable partiality. A common response is to distinguish between good and bad forms of the nation, and then show that the theoretical criticism only applies to the bad forms. Although most of these distinctions fail, one distinction seems promising: liberal nationalism, which includes the values that modern liberal readers would want in any acceptable political theory, and argues that these values are compatible with nationalism. Yet I argue that liberal nationalism also comes up short as a response. In its place I offer a new version of nationalism that starts with some of the values of the liberal nation, but which is expanded by using some of the key ideas found in Aristotle’s ethical and political writings. I argue that Aristotelian ‘Virtue Nationalism’ is a form of nationalism that is not immoral. I also argue that Aristotle’s writings offer other ideas that can be useful today, ideas that would make the Virtuous Nation superior to other types of nations currently extant. As a practical tool, I propose that this ideal be used as a guide for improving actual nation-states. Although it is an ideal and is not found anywhere, it can serve as a standard for what is considered ‘good,’ and as a measure of how far existing nations fall short. Indeed, I believe that this is its primary value for the nationalist ideology that forms the political foundation of today’s world.
Committee
Daniel Farrell (Advisor)
Pages
307 p.
Keywords
Nationalism
;
Aristotle
;
Politics
;
Ethics
;
Virtue
;
Rhetoric
Recommended Citations
Refworks
EndNote
RIS
Mendeley
Citations
Aguilar, A. P. (2007).
Virtue nationalism: an aristotelian defense of the nation
[Doctoral dissertation, Ohio State University]. OhioLINK Electronic Theses and Dissertations Center. http://rave.ohiolink.edu/etdc/view?acc_num=osu1196050100
APA Style (7th edition)
Aguilar, Abigail.
Virtue nationalism: an aristotelian defense of the nation.
2007. Ohio State University, Doctoral dissertation.
OhioLINK Electronic Theses and Dissertations Center
, http://rave.ohiolink.edu/etdc/view?acc_num=osu1196050100.
MLA Style (8th edition)
Aguilar, Abigail. "Virtue nationalism: an aristotelian defense of the nation." Doctoral dissertation, Ohio State University, 2007. http://rave.ohiolink.edu/etdc/view?acc_num=osu1196050100
Chicago Manual of Style (17th edition)
Abstract Footer
Document number:
osu1196050100
Download Count:
6,419
Copyright Info
© 2007, all rights reserved.
This open access ETD is published by The Ohio State University and OhioLINK.